Did Hallucinations Help Create Religion?

Hallucinations are a feature of our brain's hardware. Could religious visions be accounted for by this neurological phenomenon? 

Did Hallucinations Help Create Religion?

Of the many interlocking neurological and social factors that have gone into creating the phenomenon we call religion, one of the most pertinent might just be our ability to hallucinate. Hearing voices, seeing visions, and remembering events that never occurred (or foreseeing catastrophes and fantasias that never will) are all features of our neurochemical hardware.

As the late neurologist Oliver Sacks writes in Hallucinations,

Anyone with a visually monotonous task is susceptible to hallucinations. (Similarly, auditory monotony may lead to auditory hallucinations.)

Sacks cites pilots and truck drivers as two examples, people who spend hours upon hours staring at similar terrain. It’s not a stretch to imagine desert dwellers transfixed by long landscapes experiencing the same. Music producers easily fall into the audio side, which might help account for creative and psychedelic output occurring in the trance traditions of African drumming, Gnawa, qawwali, and other traditions. The visions of others captivate the rest of us.

Of the many cognitive aberrations Sacks cites in his book, epilepsy is one of the more telling in terms of religious thought—what Hippocrates dubbed the ‘sacred disease.’ The sudden onset of a seizure was, for centuries, considered proof of divine takeover, the ghost in the machine demanding its voice be heard.

Yet, like with psychedelics—another topic Sacks dissects—the ‘message’ delivered by seizures is not coherent. Many hallucinations, purposeful or otherwise, amount only to disorienting and confused moments that are only later contextualized. Our brain hates incomplete narratives. If a metaphysical entity can fill the gap, sign him up.

In order to make sense of such a startling experience, we rely on memories for inspiration—we settle on a context that is at least somewhat familiar. Interestingly, the regions of our brain that deal with memories are also activated when we contemplate the future. As psychologist Michael C. Corballis points out, in the sixteenth century the word hallucination simply meant ‘a wandering mind.’ When our minds wander, it is either forward or backward, both states removed from the present due to the same neurological real estate.

Sacks’s own usage of psychedelics is well documented. While cannabis, mescaline, and LSD were on the menu, it was an experience with Artane, a synthetic drug used by Parkinson’s patients (similar in effect to belladonna), causing his brain to wander into new dimensions. A friend suggested a hefty dose of twenty pills. He concurred.

On the Sunday morning of his exploration he was upset to find little more than a dry mouth and inability to read. Entering his kitchen he put on a kettle for tea. Two friends announced their presence in his Topanga home for breakfast, a regular custom. Sacks asked how they’d like their eggs. After their response he continued the conversation, preparing three plates. 

Meal ready, Sacks entered the living room to find no ‘they.’ The morning grew stranger when a helicopter descended toward his backyard transporting his parents. Sacks had finished all three plates by this point. Excited to see his family, he showered and dressed for this sudden visit—apparently his parents had traveled from London to Los Angeles via chopper—only to find, of course, no reunion would be had.

During this time Sacks was a resident in the UCLA neurology department. He had a firm grasp on a range of neurological abnormalities; he knew the chemical reactions occurring in his brain even if surprised by the effects. His memories—in this case, reams of research and time with patients—assured him that those voices and sounds were the unique product of neurochemistry, not actual disembodied quips from a nether world. Not everyone is so fortunate. If you have no such training, that helicopter easily becomes the chariot of the gods.

Corballis notes dualism, the idea that an ethereal body lives inside the flesh and chemistry of our being, is born of our brain’s mind wandering (or, as known in science jargon, the default mode system). We are predisposed to believe that our minds are separate from the physiological and neurological processes of our body. Social psychologist Jonathan Haidt’s work confirms this as well. 

Mind wandering is our brain’s most natural state. Slipping into central executive mode, complete focus, takes more work and fuel (in the form of glucose) than lying back and drifting. Navigating the space between these two modes in our era of distraction technologies is an almost insurmountable challenge. And so when something catches us off guard, metaphysics is an easy culprit.

Yet even with a vast knowledge of neurological conditions, we retain a juvenile attitude toward them. (How many heads bounce along as Kanye West ignorantly raps about shaking like a Parkinson’s patient?) As our brain also seeks a path of least resistance, a biological reason for that shadow over our shoulder (more than half of American adults believe in ghosts; three-quarters in angels) is not as exciting (or easy) as invoking an apparition. This could certainly have accounted for many religious visions.

Our imagination, the boundless product of mind wandering, is a wonderful evolutionary gift. Fueled for millennia by apparitions that only existed inside the head that witnessed it, our ancestors wrote epic tales inspired by visions of demons and gods. In the realm of fantasy these stories remain among the most outlandish and beautiful in literature. Treating them as reality, though, has created way more trouble than they’re worth. 

Image: Manan Vatsyayana / Getty Images

COVID-19 amplified America’s devastating health gap. Can we bridge it?

The COVID-19 pandemic is making health disparities in the United States crystal clear. It is a clarion call for health care systems to double their efforts in vulnerable communities.

Willie Mae Daniels makes melted cheese sandwiches with her granddaughter, Karyah Davis, 6, after being laid off from her job as a food service cashier at the University of Miami on March 17, 2020.

Credit: Joe Raedle/Getty Images
Sponsored by Northwell Health
  • The COVID-19 pandemic has exacerbated America's health disparities, widening the divide between the haves and have nots.
  • Studies show disparities in wealth, race, and online access have disproportionately harmed underserved U.S. communities during the pandemic.
  • To begin curing this social aliment, health systems like Northwell Health are establishing relationships of trust in these communities so that the post-COVID world looks different than the pre-COVID one.
Keep reading Show less

Decades of data suggest parenthood makes people unhappy

Decades of studies have shown parents to be less happy than their childless peers. But are the kids to blame?

(Photo by Alex Hockett / Unsplash)
Sex & Relationships
  • Folk knowledge assumes having children is the key to living a happy, meaningful life; however, empirical evidence suggests nonparents are the more cheery bunch.
  • The difference is most pronounced in countries like the United States. In countries that support pro-family policies, parents can be just as happy as their child-free peers.
  • These findings suggest that we can't rely on folk knowledge to make decisions about parenting, on either the individual or societal levels.
Keep reading Show less

Lonely? Hungry? The same part of the brain worries about both

MRI scans show that hunger and loneliness cause cravings in the same area, which suggests socialization is a need.

Credit: Dương Nhân from Pexels
Mind & Brain
  • A new study demonstrates that our brains crave social interaction with the same areas used to crave food.
  • Hungry test subjects also reported a lack of desire to socialize, proving the existence of "hanger."
  • Other studies have suggested that failure to socialize can lead to stress eating in rodents.
Keep reading Show less

A Chinese plant has evolved to hide from humans

Researchers document the first example of evolutionary changes in a plant in response to humans.

Credit: MEDIAIMAG/Adobe Stock
Surprising Science
  • A plant coveted in China for its medicinal properties has developed camouflage that makes it less likely to be spotted and pulled up from the ground.
  • In areas where the plant isn't often picked, it's bright green. In harvested areas, it's now a gray that blends into its rocky surroundings.
  • Herbalists in China have been picking the Fritillaria dealvayi plant for 2,000 years.
Keep reading Show less
Scroll down to load more…