Can the "holy grail" of weight loss medicine fight obesity?
A new study of 12,000 overweight patients shows that lorcaserin does not cause heart problems. But does that mean we should be taking it?
While climate change is the hidden known that many citizens have grown tired of hearing about, obesity faces a similar predicament. It has become so commonplace we rarely raise an eyebrow, even as it destroys us from within. Last year, research showed that more Americans are simply giving up the fight.
Currently, nearly 70 percent of American adults are considered either overweight or obese. In Western Europe, the same number of adult men claim the same percentage, with 57 percent of adult women and a quarter of children classified as overweight.
What to do? There’s good old-fashioned calorie restriction, but the sustainability of such an emotionally charged practice is always in question, especially considering the fact that once your body becomes accustomed to one weight the metabolic and physiological changes are challenging. As psychology professor David Benton puts it:
Losing weight is much easier than maintaining weight loss, yet for health reasons we need to retain the lower weight.
Which is a fact fad diet hucksters take advantage of. They exploit short-term loss by packaging it as a long-term solution. The easier to implement the better, hence the proliferation of green tea and açaí pills. So accustomed to popping a pill for any reason have we become that attempting any management solution without it seems impossible. Consider the opioid crisis: treat the symptoms instead of the cause.
Weight loss programs are of the same mindset. There is basically no intervention that does not require serious reconsideration of lifestyle habits for success, yet the focus is always on what allows you to shed pounds quickest. A pound a week has long been the healthiest target, but when people want to drop 20 or 30 pounds immediately, such humble ambitions seem ludicrous. And so a crop of “nutritional gurus” rush in to promise the impossible.
Sadly, we’re hardwired for the fantastic, however ludicrous it is over time. Which is why it’s almost refreshing to find a study with the most modest results from a pharmaceutical intervention: nine pounds lost over 40 months with no serious health implications.
Researchers have been looking into pharmacological solutions for weight loss for decades. The side effects of whatever has been packaged in pill form thus far have outweighed the benefits, most specifically pulmonary hypertension and heart-valve problems.
Since the selective serotonin 2C receptor agonist, lorcaserin, was approved by the FDA in 2012, it has been touted as a potential “holy grail” of weight loss intervention. So an extensive research team, led by Dr. Erin Bohula, a cardiovascular medicine and critical care specialist at Brigham and Women’s Hospital, put that to the test.
Twelve thousand overweight or obese patients, all of whom suffer from heart problems or display risk factors, were either given lorcaserin or a placebo. As noted, the lorcaserin group lost an average of nine pounds over 40 months. More importantly, however, that group showed no significant divergence in heart problems from the placebo group. Three earlier, small trials found similar results.
This fact caused Tom Fray, who works for Britain’s National Obesity Forum, to proclaim:
I think there will be several holy grails, but this is a holy grail and one which has been certainly at the back of the mind of a lot of specialists for a long time.
That comment came with an important disclaimer, however:
But all of the other things apply—lifestyle change has got to be root and branch part of this.
When I sent this study to a friend who is working on a postdoc in clinical psychology focusing on obesity, remarking on the average weight loss, she replied, “which you could do with a bit more exercise.”
The same conclusion I came to reading this study. As mentioned, I appreciate the modest results. Yet is the pill even necessary? Currently, Belviq (lorcaserin) can be purchased for $220-$290 a month, so it’s not an inexpensive intervention. The side effects list is also exhaustive: attentional and memory problems; depression and suicidal thoughts; slower heartbeat; constipation; headaches; dizziness; even heart valve problems, despite this latest evidence.
True, the fact that both cardiovascular problems and diabetes issues were not a factor after three years is a good sign. But if the goal is the slow and steady approach—lifestyle changes being incorporated into the weight-loss program—the pill hardly seems necessary.
Benton delivers sobering news about weight loss. It’s not a quick fix, nor does the long haul create a sexy headline. There is no “superfood” game-changer. Rather, it’s the tortoise in a media world dominated by the frenetic paces of hares—unglamorous, but sustainable.
The overwhelming message is that the price of freedom from obesity is eternal vigilance. When the initial attention associated with dieting dissipates, basic biology ensures that weight is regained. For the weight-conscious, actively counting calories can be successful, but losing weight and keeping it off can only work if one’s calorie intake becomes an issue high on the agenda.
Understanding thinking talents in yourself and others can build strong teams and help avoid burnout.
- Learn to collaborate within a team and identify "thinking talent" surpluses – and shortages.
- Angie McArthur teaches intelligent collaboration for Big Think Edge.
- Subscribe to Big Think Edge before we launch on March 30 to get 20% off monthly and annual memberships.
The Canadian professor has been on the Joe Rogan Experience six times. There's a lot of material to discuss.
- Jordan Peterson has constantly been in the headlines for his ideas on gender over the last three years.
- While on Joe Rogan's podcast, he explains his thoughts on the gender differences in society.
- On another episode, Peterson discusses the development of character through competition.
The blood of horseshoe crabs is harvested on a massive scale in order to retrieve a cell critical to medical research. However, recent innovations might make this practice obsolete.
- Horseshoe crabs' blue blood is so valuable that a quart of it can be sold for $15,000.
- This is because it contains a molecule that is crucial to the medical research community.
- Today, however, new innovations have resulted in a synthetic substitute that may end the practice of farming horseshoe crabs for their blood.
David Wallace-Wells points out that the people who can save the world just aren't all that interested.
- Saving the world from the apocalyptic impact of climate change should be a dream for many Silicon Valley titans concerned about legacy, says David Wallace-Wells, and yet few are dedicating themselves to addressing the catastrophe.
- Negative emissions technology funded by Bill Gates exists. It would cost $3 trillion per year to operate and would mean human industry could continue at current levels without global warming.
- That figure sounds astronomical, however global subsidies to fossil fuel industries cost $5 trillion per year.
SMARTER FASTER trademarks owned by The Big Think, Inc. All rights reserved.