Bookmark and Share

2:45

Part of series, Healthcare Revolution

Interview Transcript

Discuss

Default_normal

Laura Gordon on July 2, 2009, 1:56 PM

Xenotransplantation sounds like an amazing new area of research. Besides just the liver I’m curious to hear if there are other organs which are currently being looked at for cross-animal species transplant.

It is striking to me, however, that there seem to be potentially large ethical issues involved here as well. Is it right for people to “harvest” organs from animals? What would be the ramifications of this?

Default_normal

chris konar on July 26, 2009, 10:15 AM

Default_normal

chris konar on July 26, 2009, 10:21 AM

My opinion: Having had a father with serious heart disease and checking/reading copious amounts of information about heart transplants (pig hearts?) many people who had them adopted curious cravings for things like beer, pizza, many saying they never liked the stuff before the transplant? Scary, would we after having a pig transplant want to drink and eat garbage and water from a trough? Acquire diseases only pigs have? I think the folks who want to do this need to experiment on themselves first, then the rest of us can “go for it”!

Default_normal

Jane Do on July 26, 2009, 1:19 PM

The optimal goal for these people is to genetically modify humans.  In order to modify humans, they must first modify the animals.  In order for them to be able to modify the animals, they must have first been able to modify the plants (which they have already done).  There are only selfish reasons why people would want to go along with this.  

While what humans do is also “nature”, there are different scientific routes to take, as compared to politics where there are liberals and conservatives.  Genetically modifying ANY animal can be considered EXTREME liberalism on a scientific perspective.  Engineerng a human liver, per se, which does NOT change genetic makeup, and strictly using human umbilical cords to make one, would be considered a conservative direction to this type of medicine.


Add a Comment

You must be logged in to comment. Log in or Register