Bookmark and Share

5:40

Interview Transcript

Discuss

Default_normal

william miller on January 16, 2008, 2:47 PM

Regarding whether or not we, as Americans, are morally justified in spreading our enlightened way of living… perhaps we should be fairly certain that or ideas are capable of solving such problems as our nation faces. And there are many such problems: sustainability and environmental destruction come to mind.

Default_normal

william miller on January 16, 2008, 2:50 PM

p.s. I sincerely hope that our solutions to such problems can be found through science and reason- the age-old alternative being natural selection!

Default_normal

william miller on January 16, 2008, 7:47 PM

Regarding whether or not we, as Americans, are morally justified in spreading our enlightened way of living… perhaps we should be fairly certain that or ideas are capable of solving such problems as our nation faces. And there are many such problems: sustainability and environmental destruction come to mind.

Default_normal

william miller on January 16, 2008, 7:50 PM

p.s. I sincerely hope that our solutions to such problems can be found through science and reason- the age-old alternative being natural selection!

User_rnoa_e7bf1203d

James Townsend on January 28, 2008, 10:22 AM

x

Default_normal

Musycks on March 13, 2008, 3:55 PM

Sam Harris is one of the sharpest thinkers to emerge in recent years. His book "The End of Faith' I carried with me touring the USA last year.. I used to carry it through airports cover out, just for fun. Only one woman in Salt Lake City commented, and that was to say she would love to live to see the 'end of faith'!
I love his clarity and simple elegance, and while I don't agree with all he says, his overall message should be shouted to the (godless) heavens.

Default_normal

Musycks on March 13, 2008, 7:55 PM

Sam Harris is one of the sharpest thinkers to emerge in recent years. His book "The End of Faith’ I carried with me touring the USA last year.. I used to carry it through airports cover out, just for fun. Only one woman in Salt Lake City commented, and that was to say she would love to live to see the ‘end of faith’!
I love his clarity and simple elegance, and while I don’t agree with all he says, his overall message should be shouted to the (godless) heavens.

User_rkgr_92111d3f9

brendan p on March 15, 2008, 9:10 AM

he didn't answer the question: is it more likely that something sparked the big bang, or that the big bang sparked itself from nothingness.

the question had nothing to do with a personal abrahamic god. is there a possibility of a creator? yes or no. his simulation response still begs the question of an initial creator to whomever created those who made the simulation.

he could respond by asking who created the creator, which is a fair point.

but it needs to be said that science has as much or as little to say about the moment of the big bang as does any religion. the laws of science break down at the moment of our universe's creation.

User_rkgr_92111d3f9

brendan p on March 15, 2008, 1:10 PM

he didn’t answer the question: is it more likely that something sparked the big bang, or that the big bang sparked itself from nothingness.

the question had nothing to do with a personal abrahamic god. is there a possibility of a creator? yes or no. his simulation response still begs the question of an initial creator to whomever created those who made the simulation.

he could respond by asking who created the creator, which is a fair point.

but it needs to be said that science has as much or as little to say about the moment of the big bang as does any religion. the laws of science break down at the moment of our universe’s creation.

User_rfhe_80013325c

Mary Coyote on March 29, 2008, 9:44 PM

verbal pocketplay posted: 'he didn't answer the question'

Yes he did. How could a super-loving super-intelligent entity give humankind give such poor quality Holy Books. Books that do not agree, and worse, contradict each other; books that convey hatred and violence towards the other, the unbeliever, slaves, women and children. Obviously god is NOT intelligent or loving, or that these books were written by human culture's attempts to explain their ignorance.

So, a creator as these books proposes is impossible. Now if you are looking for a creator without religion, then that is science, and we are still looking.

User_rfhe_80013325c

Mary Coyote on March 30, 2008, 1:44 AM

verbal pocketplay posted: ‘he didn’t answer the question’

Yes he did. How could a super-loving super-intelligent entity give humankind give such poor quality Holy Books. Books that do not agree, and worse, contradict each other; books that convey hatred and violence towards the other, the unbeliever, slaves, women and children. Obviously god is NOT intelligent or loving, or that these books were written by human culture’s attempts to explain their ignorance.

So, a creator as these books proposes is impossible. Now if you are looking for a creator without religion, then that is science, and we are still looking.

User_raqe_67825d555

Cleo Aquitaine on June 3, 2008, 5:37 AM

Yes, there is the possibility of a creator, as Sam points out, the hypothesis that there is, is unfalsifiable.

This fact should be set against the evidence for there not being such an omnipresent God. Even in the absence of science, sheer intelligent reason should tell us that most if not all of the claims for and about the Abrahamic God and the bible are groundless.

User_raqe_67825d555

Cleo Aquitaine on June 3, 2008, 9:37 AM

Yes, there is the possibility of a creator, as Sam points out, the hypothesis that there is, is unfalsifiable.

This fact should be set against the evidence for there not being such an omnipresent God. Even in the absence of science, sheer intelligent reason should tell us that most if not all of the claims for and about the Abrahamic God and the bible are groundless.


Add a Comment

You must be logged in to comment. Log in or Register