Bookmark and Share

5:31

Interview Transcript

Discuss

Default_normal

Tim Sheiner on April 6, 2009, 4:58 PM

Jeffrey;

I’m a fan. I think you are always spot-on with your analysis, and great at communicating your ideas.

I do, however, have one quibble with this piece. As I understand you, here you are presenting the idea that web design is finally starting to understand that not only does one not need to re-invent the wheel, there is huge value in building on top of existing systems. I agree with this.

The part I have a bit of a problem with is that even this stage is still re-inventing the wheel if one takes a perspective that extends out to the design of physical objects. In other words, interchangeable parts, systems approach, standards, etc. have been a well understood part of the disciplines of physical design (product design, architecture, etc.) for a long time. If one looks at the standard processes in these disciplines it becomes clear that web design (really software design) is still in the process of re-inventing some pretty fundamental design principles.

To a certain extent the re-design is required because the analogy between software and physical objects is not perfect (a software button is not actually the same as a physical button). However, if we, as a discipline, had been more willing to recognize that the design part of what we do is analogous to other, ancient, forms of design, we might have been able to get to maturity a bit faster.

We also might not assume that we have finished re-inventing the wheel.

Tim

Default_normal

tim hall on May 4, 2009, 6:23 PM

What Tim S. is saying here makes perfect sense to me. The internet was originally created by some geeks for military communication. It was not created with “design” in mind. So we are slowly getting rid of the original creation and designing something that works for all apps. I find it funny how web designers talk about how great this or that software is. I look at what InDesign can do for desktop publishing and I see web software as being very limited. CSS is so lame in that perspective, but I am not an engineer so all I can do is complain. If there was an open source software like Indesign built for the web, I would never take a print job again.

User_rmoy_387b0c231

Rob Hunter on May 19, 2009, 9:09 PM

Thanks for this Jeffrey. You should come back soon, this is great stuff.


Add a Comment

You must be logged in to comment. Log in or Register