Spreading good ideas with someone you know is one of the simplest things we can do to improve the conversation.

Permalink for this idea

•  BUZZ
•  DELICIOUS
•  DIGG
•  FACEBOOK
•  LINKEDIN
•  EMAIL

Sign up for the Big Think newsletter in order to get pertinent thoughts and commentary delivered to your email.

Get Daily RSS Newsletter Get the Big Think Brief

Select the content feed of your choice in order to get pertinent thoughts and commentary flowing into your RSS reader.

• iraq
• Howard Zinn
• These Comments
• All Experts
• Big Think Blog

Follow these topics and ideas elsewhere

• Find on Google

  • Howard Zinn
  • iraq

• Find on Twitter

  • Howard Zinn
  • iraq

• Find on Wikipedia

  • Howard Zinn
  • iraq

Spreading good ideas with someone you know is one of the simplest things we can do to improve the conversation.

• 
  Robert Austin replied on 08:07 AM on June 11, 2008
  Why don%u2019t we allow the Iraqis to hold a nationwide referendum on whether or not the United States should promptly withdraw from Iraq? I have been wondering about this for some time. I have never seen this idea seriously proposed by anyone in our government, but it seems so obvious to me. The Bush administration touts that it has brought democracy to Iraq, and the world has seen elections successfully held in there. A referendum of the sort I propose is good for both the United States and Iraq. If the Iraqis vote %u201CYes, the United States should leave,%u201D the United States could then withdraw without losing face and without emboldening Al Qaeda, since our withdrawal would be implemented out of respect for the will of the Iraqi people, not be due to a loss of will on behalf of the United States. Alternatively, if the Iraqis say, %u201CNo, the United States should stay to help maintain stability,%u201D the United States can justify its continued presence in Iraq to itself and to the rest of the world. The United States would then be seen as a peace keeping nation rather than an occupying nation.
  • Reply
  • Hide
  • Flag
  • #1
  • • 1
    • 2
    • 3
• Tree Roland replied on 08:44 AM on June 11, 2008
  I love Howard Zinn's proposal for getting out of Iraq -- "Put the troops on trucks, and head for the border."
  • Reply
  • Hide
  • Flag
  • #2
  • • 1
    • 2
    • 3
• 
  Robert Austin replied on 12:07 PM on June 11, 2008
  Why don%u2019t we allow the Iraqis to hold a nationwide referendum on whether or not the United States should promptly withdraw from Iraq? I have been wondering about this for some time. I have never seen this idea seriously proposed by anyone in our government, but it seems so obvious to me. The Bush administration touts that it has brought democracy to Iraq, and the world has seen elections successfully held in there. A referendum of the sort I propose is good for both the United States and Iraq. If the Iraqis vote %u201CYes, the United States should leave,%u201D the United States could then withdraw without losing face and without emboldening Al Qaeda, since our withdrawal would be implemented out of respect for the will of the Iraqi people, not be due to a loss of will on behalf of the United States. Alternatively, if the Iraqis say, %u201CNo, the United States should stay to help maintain stability,%u201D the United States can justify its continued presence in Iraq to itself and to the rest of the world. The United States would then be seen as a peace keeping nation rather than an occupying nation.
  • Reply
  • Hide
  • Flag
  • #3
  • • 1
    • 2
    • 3
• Tree Roland replied on 12:44 PM on June 11, 2008
  I love Howard Zinn's proposal for getting out of Iraq -- "Put the troops on trucks, and head for the border."
  • Reply
  • Hide
  • Flag
  • #4
  • • 1
    • 2
    • 3

Sign up or log in to post a response to this idea.

Sharing good ideas with peers is one of the simplest things we can do to improve the conversation. Please share good conversation starters here for others to discuss.

Sign up or log in to post a response to this idea.

Howard Zinn on Iraq: Advice for the Next President

Howard Zinn Historian

• All My Ideas
• Contact Me

Question: What should the next President do to get the military out of Iraq?

Howard Zinn: I think the next president should begin, announce the immediate withdrawal of American troops from Iraq. I think this will be a very healthy thing for Iraq. The American occupation has not helped a thing. It has not stopped civil war; it has provoked civil war. It has not given the Iraqi people security or democracy; it has given them the opposite. It has ruined their country. And, of course, it has ruined our country, too. The most important thing is for the Iraqis. I think the next president should announce the immediate withdrawal and he should call upon the international community--the UN, the Arab States--to convene an international body to mediate in Iraq among the different groups, among the Shiites and the Sunnis and the Kurds and try to work out--and this is what the United States should not do--try to work out a compromised solution for the conflicts among them. I say to not try to work out a compromised solution. The United States moved in, shock and awe with enormous force, set the Shiites up in power, moved the Sunnis out and created the conditions for the present civil war. So getting out, trying to help with an international group, using our resources to give food and medicine and restore clean water and all the fundamental things that the Iraqis have been deprived of because of the war. In other words, we can begin to do constructive things, rather than continuing the destruction.

Recorded on: 7/5/08

Read full transcript »

Howard Zinn Historian

• Contact Me

Howard Zinn is a historian, political scientist, social critic, activist and playwright, best known as author of the bestseller A People’s History of the United States.

Zinn has been active in the Civil Rights and anti-war movements in the United States.

The author of some 20 books, Zinn is currently Professor Emeritus in the Political Science Department at Boston University. He lives in Massachusetts with his wife, the artist Roslyn Zinn. The couple have two children, Myla and Jeff, and five grandchildren. Both artist and editor, Roslyn has had a role in editing all of Zinn’s books and many of his articles.

Read more about Howard Zinn »

• 
  John McCain on NAFTA NAFTA has created millions of jobs, says McCain.
• 
  Thomas Cooley: How Can You Make The Most Of Technological Revolution? The Dean of the NYU Stern School of Business, Thomas Cooley, on how technol
• Geithner Answers Questions on His Financial Plan
• Letterman Writer Gives Full Frontal Nudity the OK
• Having Sex With Lolita in Tehran
• Eleven Technologies That Will Revolutionize Business
• How to Be a Smart Adopter
• Michael Bloomberg Action Plan
• Ricky Gervais on Religion
• Ray Kurzweil on Living Well Forever
• Eight Ways Microblogging Will Transform Your Company

• 
  Mary Roach Author / Journalist 1
• 
  Eric Kocher Staff Sergeant 2
• 
  Steven Castellano Student Scientist, High Technology High School 3
• 
  Clay Shirky Professor of New Media; Author, Here Comes Everybody 4
• 
  Elizabeth Gilbert Author 5
• 
  Paul Krugman Professor of Economics, Princeton; Columnist, The New York Times 6