Question: Was NAFTA a good idea?
Dennis Kucinich: Well of course it was a bad idea. It was a bad idea because NAFTA was written specifically to drive down wages. I mean Ross Perot was right. When he warned America that we were going to lose millions of jobs, he was 100 percent right. He knew what the Democrats at that point weren’t ready to say, and that is that NAFTA was going to cause America to lose millions of jobs because wages would . . . because manufacturers . . . corporations would seek other countries where wages were lower; where workers didn’t have any rights at all; where they could make a bigger profit. Now let’s think about this for a minute. It was a democratic president who passed NAFTA – President Clinton. When he passed it, the Democrats lost the Congress in the next election. Why? Because people just lost confidence that Democrats would protect their wages and protect their jobs. In this election, you have many people running for president who voted for NAFTA, or who supported NAFTA. And I wasn’t in the Congress, but I made my position very clear right from the beginning that there should be no trade agreements unless they include workers rights, human rights, and environmental quality principles. Let’s look at where we are right now. We’ve lost millions of jobs to NAFTA. We’re losing millions more due to China trade. As president, my first act in office will be to cancel NAFTA and get out of the WTO, and to have trade based on those workers’ rights principles; plus protection of the air, the water and the land; environmental principles; plus prohibitions on child labor, trade labor . . . or slave labor and prison labor. So I offer that to you for your consideration because trade is one of those areas where the democratic parties absolutely failed the American people – sold them out. And I’m the one Democrat who understands that workers need a president who isn’t going to be mourning while there’s grass growing in parking lots where there used to grow . . . where they used to make steel, cars, washing machines, bicycles, automotive supplies, and now there’s grass growing in parking lots.
Recorded on: 10/19/07
Discuss
P Conner on January 9, 2008, 12:19 PM
NAFTA is a very bad idea for the American worker. An American worker cannot compete with the low-wages paid to a Mexician worker.
There is a huge sucking sound of American jobs being outsourced to Mexico. That is a loss of revenue to the US in the form of taxes and lower wages for the American worker.
P Conner on January 9, 2008, 5:19 PM
NAFTA is a very bad idea for the American worker. An American worker cannot compete with the low-wages paid to a Mexician worker.
There is a huge sucking sound of American jobs being outsourced to Mexico. That is a loss of revenue to the US in the form of taxes and lower wages for the American worker.
Jonathan Adamski on January 16, 2008, 9:33 AM
Very sad indeed. Look at Michigan and tell me NAFTA is a good idea.
Jonathan Adamski on January 16, 2008, 2:33 PM
Very sad indeed. Look at Michigan and tell me NAFTA is a good idea.
Nelson harbor on February 26, 2008, 12:16 PM
During the last decade in this country, numerous small town economies have been completely destroyed by NAFTA, as corporation after corporation decided to move complete production facilities to Mexico.
On the flip side, when you consider the ever-increasing number of illegal workers leaving Mexico to enter the US in search of jobs during the same period, you have to wonder if either country has really benefited by NAFTA?
Corporations have benefited greatly from NAFTA's lower wage costs. That is all that NAFTA has brought to America: cheap labor.
Nelson harbor on February 26, 2008, 5:16 PM
During the last decade in this country, numerous small town economies have been completely destroyed by NAFTA, as corporation after corporation decided to move complete production facilities to Mexico.
On the flip side, when you consider the ever-increasing number of illegal workers leaving Mexico to enter the US in search of jobs during the same period, you have to wonder if either country has really benefited by NAFTA?
Corporations have benefited greatly from NAFTA’s lower wage costs. That is all that NAFTA has brought to America: cheap labor.
Add a Comment
You must be logged in to comment. Log in or Register