Perhaps it is because when one reviews the remarks on a topic that demands logic and analysis, the responders often do not use logic or analysis. From the number of irrational, inane, and faith-based responses, it appears responders here do not, all to often, know how to apply logic.
This ensures that no idea will be developed in a rational way. No matter what is discussed or where, there will be Warrior3, or someone like her/him, who will be there to ensure irrationality and prevent co-operative analysis. Boredom and flaming is sure to follow. No big thinkers will endure that for long.